

Anna, orphaned at a young age, is raised by her mother's friend, Mrs. Kane, alongside foster brothers Gordy and Jonathan. As the football team's manager, she is the heart of their success until the jealous school beauty, Katie, drives a wedge between them with her schemes. Heartbroken, Anna transfers schools and becomes football star Ethan's personal manager. By the time Gordy and Jonathan uncover Katie's lies, Anna has already found a new future, standing beside Ethan as they celebrate a championship victory together.

The night before his wedding, while decorating the venue, Scott Brawley receives a fire alarm call from their new house. Rushing over, he discovers his fiancee Alison Ritchie in bed with her stepbrother. Alison shamelessly claims it's just "sibling affection" that won't affect tomorrow's wedding. Reflecting on the past,Scott realizes how many times Alison has hurt him for her stepbrother's sake. He always thought marriage would fix things, but seeing the ambiguous kiss marks on Alison's body,Scott finally wakes up. He agrees to his grandfather's arrangement. Tomorrow, he'll marry the arranged bride instead.

Matthew Tipton is one breakthrough away from immortality, held back only by unresolved mortal ties. Sent down the mountain to cut them loose, he finds Cristal Bridges, a woman who wants nothing to do with her father's arranged marriage and makes that very clear. But trouble keeps finding Cristal, and Matthew keeps stepping in to pull her out of it. Somewhere between reluctant proximity and quiet acts of protection, feelings take root that neither of them planned for. The immortal who came to leave ends up staying forever.